Lord of the Rings Fanatics Plaza

I may be considered a weapon.
I am not an emblem.
Elves did not make me.
The Dwarves did not forge me.
Humans have forged parts of me.
Yes, the TLoTR mentions me.
A Hobbit(s) used me.
Yes, the TTT mentions me.
As I said previously, Elves did not make me. I am not the phial that Galadriel prepared and gave to Frodo.
Yes, the Hobbits from The Fellowship use me.
No, I am not a stone.
No, not by Merry or Pippin.
Sam does use me.
Frodo does use me.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Rivendell.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Lothlórien.

Did Frodo possess it before going into Cirith Ungol?

Hmmm, if you mean the Tower of Cirith Ungol, no.

Can you be held in one hand?

I may be considered a weapon.
I am not an emblem.
Elves did not make me.
The Dwarves did not forge me.
Humans have forged parts of me.
Yes, the TLoTR mentions me.
A Hobbit(s) used me.
Yes, the TTT mentions me.
As I said previously, Elves did not make me. I am not the phial that Galadriel prepared and gave to Frodo.
Yes, the Hobbits from The Fellowship use me.
No, I am not a stone.
No, not by Merry or Pippin.
Sam does use me.
Frodo does use me.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Rivendell.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Lothlórien.
Hmmm, if you mean the Tower of Cirith Ungol, no.
No Orcs forged me that I know of.
One hand can hold me.

Did Frodo have you before leaving Mordor?

It doesn't say, but I don't think Frodo left Mordor with me.

Did Frodo return to the Shire with you?

I may be considered a weapon.
I am not an emblem.
Elves did not make me.
The Dwarves did not forge me.
Humans have forged parts of me.
Yes, the TLoTR mentions me.
A Hobbit(s) used me.
Yes, the TTT mentions me.
As I said previously, Elves did not make me. I am not the phial that Galadriel prepared and gave to Frodo.
Yes, the Hobbits from The Fellowship use me.
No, I am not a stone.
No, not by Merry or Pippin.
Sam does use me.
Frodo does use me.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Rivendell.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Lothlórien.
Hmmm, if you mean the Tower of Cirith Ungol, no.
No Orcs forged me that I know of.
One hand can hold me.
It doesn't say, but I don't think Frodo left Mordor with me.
Frodo did not return to the Shire with me.

Is it Frodos water bottle?

I may be considered a weapon.
I am not an emblem.
Elves did not make me.
The Dwarves did not forge me.
Humans have forged parts of me.
Yes, the TLoTR mentions me.
A Hobbit(s) used me.
Yes, the TTT mentions me.
As I said previously, Elves did not make me. I am not the phial that Galadriel prepared and gave to Frodo.
Yes, the Hobbits from The Fellowship use me.
No, I am not a stone.
No, not by Merry or Pippin.
Sam does use me.
Frodo does use me.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Rivendell.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Lothlórien.
Hmmm, if you mean the Tower of Cirith Ungol, no.
No Orcs forged me that I know of.
One hand can hold me.
It doesn't say, but I don't think Frodo left Mordor with me.
Frodo did not return to the Shire with me.
I am not part of the armour that Sam and Frodo wore.
I am not Frodo's water bottle.

Did Frodo acquire you when he was with Faramir?

I may be considered a weapon.
I am not an emblem.
Elves did not make me.
The Dwarves did not forge me.
Humans have forged parts of me.
Yes, the TLoTR mentions me.
A Hobbit(s) used me.
Yes, the TTT mentions me.
As I said previously, Elves did not make me. I am not the phial that Galadriel prepared and gave to Frodo.
Yes, the Hobbits from The Fellowship use me.
No, I am not a stone.
No, not by Merry or Pippin.
Sam does use me.
Frodo does use me.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Rivendell.
No, Frodo did not possess it before leaving Lothlórien.
Hmmm, if you mean the Tower of Cirith Ungol, no.
No Orcs forged me that I know of.
One hand can hold me.
It doesn't say, but I don't think Frodo left Mordor with me.
Frodo did not return to the Shire with me.
I am not part of the armour that Sam and Frodo wore.
I am not Frodo's water bottle.
Yes, Frodo did acquire me when he was with Faramir.

Are you Frodos lebethron staff that he got from Faramir?

That is a close enough guess for me. I was looking for the two staves that Frodo and Sam got from Faramir.

The hobbits' packs were brought to them (a little heavier
than they had been), and also two stout staves of polished
wood, shod with iron, and with carven heads through which
ran plaited leathern thongs.
'I have no fitting gifts to give you at our parting,' said
Faramir; 'but take these staves. They may be of service to
those who walk or climb in the wild. The men of the White
Mountains use them; though these have been cut down to
your height and newly shod. They are made of the fair tree
lebethron, beloved of the woodwrights of Gondor, and a virtue
has been set upon them of finding and returning. May that
Virtue not wholly fail under the Shadow into which you go! TTT, Journey To The Cross-Roads

Yup those were the ones I was thinking of.

Time to mix it up: Where am I?

Are you in a forest?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).

Are you habitable?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.

Are you made of water?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.

Do you contain any structures?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.

Are you the Pastures of Yavanna?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
WhileI am not named on the map, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
WhileI am not named on the map, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
WhileI am not named on the map, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
WhileI am not named on the map, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.

Did any member of the Fellowship of the Ring ever visit or enter this place?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
WhileI am not named on the map, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.
I am not the bushes where the Fellowship hid.

An important note from earlier is that this locations is in a forest, not in Eriador, but the forest that it is located in is on the map of Eriador.

Are you the troll cave?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.
I am not the bushes where the Fellowship hid.
I am not in the troll cave

So you are in one of the forests on the map of Middle-earth?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.
I am not the bushes where the Fellowship hid.
I am not in the troll cave.
I am in one of the forests on the map of Middle-Earth but my exact location in the forest is not noted.

Did two members of the Fellowship visit you?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.
I am not the bushes where the Fellowship hid.
I am not in the troll cave.
I am in one of the forests on the map of Middle-Earth but my exact location in the forest is not noted.
Two members of the Fellowship visited me.