Lord of the Rings Fanatics Plaza

Did three members of the Fellowship visit you?

I am in a forest.
I am not on the map of the island Ilmaren to the best of my knowledge (not certain of the exact map you are referring to).
I would not call it habitable.
I am not made of water.
I am not found on the map of Beleriand.
I do not contain any structures.
While I am not named on the of Eriador, but I am located within the area covered by the map.
I am not the Pastures of Yavanna
I am not in the Shire.
I am not north of Eriador.
I am not in Eriador.
Yes, members of the Fellowship visited me.
I am not the eastern road west of the Hithaeglir.
I am not the bushes where the Fellowship hid.
I am not in the troll cave.
I am in one of the forests on the map of Middle-Earth but my exact location in the forest is not noted.
Two members of the Fellowship visited me.
Three members of the Fellowship did not visit me.

Are you the valley where the Entmoot was held, in Fangorn forest?

I am indeed that place, Derndingle!
The floor is yours!

Hurray! Thank you very much. That was a good one.

Let me see... Who am I?

Are you an elf?

Yes, I am an Elf.

Does your storyline take place in the First Age?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.

Are you male?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.

Are you a descendant of Finwë?

That's a difficult one... but I'd say yes.

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I am a descendant of Finwë.

Are you of Sindarin descent?

Did you meet any Hobbits?

In retrospect, I have to change a bit about the earlier answer about being a descendent of Finwë, because I can not be 100% sure (or at least I cannot find it).
The same can be said about the Sindarin descent.

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.

Are you a leader?

Yes, this 'who' is leading.

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.

Do you have golden hair?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.
The colour of my hair is not known.

Is your name known?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.
The colour of my hair is not known.
My name is known.

Are you Gildor Inglorion?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.
The colour of my hair is not known.
My name is known.
I am not Gildor Inglorion.

Are you in The Hobbit?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.
The colour of my hair is not known.
My name is known.
I am not Gildor Inglorion.
I am not in the Hobbit.

Are you in The Two Towers?

Are you connected to the Company of the Ring in any way?

I am an Elf.
My storyline does not take place in the First Age.
I am male.
I might be descendant of Finwë.
I might be of Sindarin descent.
I did indeed meet any Hobbits.
I am a leader.
The colour of my hair is not known.
My name is known.
I am not Gildor Inglorion.
I am not in the Hobbit.
I am not in The Two Towers
I am connected to the Company of the Ring
I am part of Elrond's Household

Are you Erestor?

Yes!
I am Erestor, chief (leader) of the counsellors of Elrond, also kinsman of Elrond (but not known along which family line so I couldn't tell if he was descending from Finwë or if he was of Sindarin descent).

Excellent choice, and yeah when you gave those answers I figured it was going to be someone like that.

Let's mix it up a little bit with a...

What am I?

Thank you! I enjoyed it.
Let me see...

Are you a weapon or a thing that was used as a weapon?

Are you a plant?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.

Are you of Elven origin?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.

Are you made of some form of metal alloy?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.
A significant portion of me is made of metal, but not all of me.

Were you still in existence/used in the Third Age?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.
A significant portion of me is made of metal, but not all of me.
I was not used in the Third Age. I likely still exist but almost certainly not functional or accessible.

Are you a spear of some form?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.
A significant portion of me is made of metal, but not all of me.
I was not used in the Third Age. I likely still exist but almost certainly not functional or accessible.
I am not a spear.

Was your owner/yielder mortal?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.
A significant portion of me is made of metal, but not all of me.
I was not used in the Third Age. I likely still exist but almost certainly not functional or accessible.
I am not a spear.
It depends on how you define mortal, but my owner did die.

I'll define my question a bit more: was your last owner a mortal man?

I am a weapon or have been used as a weapon.
I am not a plant.
While my exact origin is not explicitly stated, I am almost certainly of Elven origin.
A significant portion of me is made of metal, but not all of me.
I was not used in the Third Age. I likely still exist but almost certainly not functional or accessible.
I am not a spear.
It depends on how you define mortal, but my owner did die.
My only known owner was an elf.
My last owner was not a mortal man.

Do you have a name given to you?