Periantar, that you guessed the right answer is not disputed. You are the riddle-guesser and so only you have the authority to speak on the riddle itself, which is disputed. Did you guess the right answer to the wrong riddle?
While you were napping i tried to work this out and went to the admins for help, which helped not at all (though i saw some new bits of this nuplaza). Thing is, i'm also a bit new to this nuplaza and i think i went to the wrong place - this is obviously a case for the Lore Goose.
Again, i'm not quite sure how this works - older members please feel free to step in. But it seems straightforward. Legally, all members address the Judge (the Goose), who meanwhile has sat on her spectacles and reads the wrong post. The members of the court - you, me, Drifa, anyone else who cares to toss a coin in the hat - then sort out the matter ourselves. When we are done we poke the Goose again who gives a formal ruling. Something like that.
So, as you already know riddle and answer, here is the issue:
Please, please, please your Hobbitness, shed some light on this Riddle so that we can fix the riddle thread. To be honest with you, the reason that we have to sort the court thing out ourselves in Lore is because the Goose has nobly sat on the Fangorn riddle thread to keep the whole riddle-magic flowing - which is a great deed, indeed, but we will flounder in Lore without the Goose, so we are looking to u to step up to the plate to provide a more permanent riddle-thread solution. please help!Drifa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 17, 2023 3:57 pm In TROTK Appendix C Family Trees:...Most of them are either guests at Bilbo's Farewell Party, or their direct ancestors. The guests at the Party are underlined.Falco Chubb-Baggins
1303 - 1399
Poppy
1344
= Filibert Bolger
Was Poppy married at the time of the Party and no longer a Chubb-Baggins????