Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?

[Arothir]

I am in a forest.
I am not in a forest in the Third Age.
I am not inhabited.
I am not a building in a forest
I am not a dark forest, but I am located in one that became dark.
I am not a stone.
I was never properly inhabited, but I have been camped at.
I am not where Bilbo met the three trolls.
There have been many notable deaths in the forest I am in but the only death at my location is a person known only by their rank, not by a name.
The title had nothing to do with a female's death.
The rank was, indeed, captain.

[Drífa]

Are you in Dorthonion?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you in one of these forests: Brethil, Neldoreth or Region that from together the kingdom of Doriath? There are spots, where is camped, and turning dark in later centuries...

[Arothir]

I am in a forest.
I am not in a forest in the Third Age.
I am not inhabited.
I am not a building in a forest
I am not a dark forest, but I am located in one that became dark.
I am not a stone.
I was never properly inhabited, but I have been camped at.
I am not where Bilbo met the three trolls.
There have been many notable deaths in the forest I am in but the only death at my location is a person known only by their rank, not by a name.
The title had nothing to do with a female's death.
The rank was, indeed, captain.
I am in Dorthonion.
I am not anywhere in Doriath.

[Drífa]

Ah, very good. 'Where am I?' It took me a while; honestly, I have never read about this place.

Are you Rivil's Well, where Beren slew the Orc captain that had his father's hand and ring?

[Arothir]

I am, indeed, Rivil's Well.

[Drífa]

I must rephrase that I have read about Beren slaying the Orc, but did not register the place, Rivil's Well. That's a good one!

What am I?

[Arothir]

Were you made before the First Age?

[Drífa]

It is not stated that I was made or that I was before the First Age.

[Arothir]

Are you mentioned in The Hobbit?

[Drífa]

It is not stated that I was made or that I was before the First Age.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.

[Arothir]

Are you an object?

[Drífa]

I am considered an object in certain contexts.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you made of natural materials?

[Arothir]

Were you made by an elf?

[Drífa]

It is not stated that I was made or that I was before the First Age.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
Yes, I am made of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I would say I am not.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Am I used in the Third Age?

[Arothir]

Are you used by a member of the Fellowship?

[Drífa]

I have clarified some of my replies. I hope it helps.

It is not stated before the First Age but is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, I am made of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I would say I am not.
I am only mentioned in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.

[Arothir]

Are you an item that is worn?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Does this item travel with the Fellowship on their journey to either Mordor, Rohan or Gondor?

[Drífa]

Again, I have clarified some of my replies. I hope it helps. My apologies. I am having trouble with my passive voice.

It is not stated before the First Age but is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been.
No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor, Rohan, or Gondor.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you mentioned by one of the Hobbits?

[Arothir]

Are you mentioned by either of the men in the Fellowship?

[Drífa]

It is not stated before the First Age but is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been.
No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor, Rohan, or Gondor.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Is it Legolas who mentioned the item?

[Drífa]

It is not stated before the First Age but is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been.
No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor, Rohan, or Gondor.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Hmm, then it is surely something that I covered when I wrote Account from Rhovanion. But in what leg of the journey? Legolas doesn't elaborate much about his homeland. Is something he said on the river section, to Gimli?

[Drífa]

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.

[Arothir]

Are you Legolas' part of the Song of Boromir?

[Drífa]

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Is it the song "To the Sea", sung by Legolas? The grey ship perhaps, it is made from natural materials?

To the Sea, to the Sea! The white gulls are crying,
The wind is blowing, and the white foam is flying.
West, west away, the round sun is falling.
Grey ship, grey ship, do you hear them calling.
The voices of my people that have gone before me?
I will leave, I will leave the woods that bore me;
For our days are ending and our years failing.
I will pass the wide waters lonely sailing.
Long are the waves on the Last Shore falling,
Sweet are the voices in the Lost Isle calling,
In Eressëa, in Elvenhome that no man can discover,
Where the leaves fall not: land of my people for ever!'_

[Arothir]

Are you a song/poem?

[Drífa]

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but I could have been worn.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Legolas's song of Nimrodel?

An Elven-maid there was of old,
A shining star by day:
Her mantle white was hemmed with gold,
Her shoes of silver-grey.

[Drífa]

I adjusted some of my responses because Grammarly kept pestering me.

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but in all likelihood, I am wearable.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.
I am not a song.

I previously highlighted specific answers in red as hints. I am sure a song is not an object or can be worn.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

It is the Nimrodel song then since you didn't say it was not, and more specified... "Her mantle white was hemmed with gold" or "Her shoes of silver-grey." I posted the alinea since there is the possible item in it, that you are? The mantle or the shoes?

[Drífa]

No, Aiks. It is not the song of Nimrodel.

I am not in the song if Nimrodel.

[Arothir]

Are you in the Song of Boromir?

[Drífa]

I adjusted some of my responses because Grammarly kept pestering me.

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but in all likelihood, I am wearable.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.
I am not a song.
I previously highlighted specific answers in red as hints. I am sure a song is not an object or can be worn.
I am not in the song of Nimrodel.
I am sure I already said I am not the Song of Boromir. I am sure I said I am not a song.

[Arothir]

Oh I was referring to an item mentioned in the song, my apologies.

Are you mentioned in The Two Towers?

[Drífa]

No need to apologize, Arothir.

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but in all likelihood, I am wearable.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.
I am not a song.
I previously highlighted specific answers in red as hints. I am sure a song is not an object or can be worn.
I am not in the song of Nimrodel.
I am sure I already said I am not the Song of Boromir. I am sure I said I am not a song.
I am not in the song for Boromir.
I am not in TTT.

[Arothir]

Are you mentioned in The Fellowship of the Ring?

[Drífa]

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but in all likelihood, I am wearable.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.
I am not a song.
I previously highlighted specific answers in red as hints. I am sure a song is not an object or can be worn.
I am not in the song of Nimrodel.
I am sure I already said I am not the Song of Boromir. I am sure I said I am not a song.
I am not in the song for Boromir.
I am not in TTT.
I am not mentioned in TFOTR.

[Arothir]

Are you a gull?

[Drífa]

Before the First Age, there is no mention, but it is most likely.
No, there is no mention of me in The Hobbit.
I am considered an object in specific contexts.
Yes, of natural materials.
It does not state that elves made me, yet I believe I am not.
I am mentioned only in the Third Age.
A member of the Fellowship mentioned me.
It does not state that anyone wore me, but in all likelihood, I am wearable.
Clarification: No, I did not travel physically with the Fellowship on their journey to Mordor or Rohan, but I did travel to Gondor, and mentioned.
Hobbits did not mention me.
Men in the Fellowship do not mention me.
It is Legolas who mentions me.
There is no mention of me on the river.
I am in a song. I am not that song, for Boromir.
I am not in, To The Sea.
I am in a song.
I am not a song.
I previously highlighted specific answers in red as hints. I am sure a song is not an object or can be worn.
I am not in the song of Nimrodel.
I am sure I already said I am not the Song of Boromir. I am sure I said I am not a song.
I am not in the song for Boromir.
I am not in TTT.
I am not mentioned in TFOTR.
I am not a gull. I don't have legs.

[Arothir]

Are you mallos?

[Drífa]

Wonderful! And you guessed the correct flower, mallos. I was a little concerned about that, seeing as how there are two three flowers mentioned.

Legolas paused and sighed, and turning his eyes southward softly he sang:

Silver flow the streams from Celos to Erui
In the green fields of Lebennin!
Tall grows the grass there. In the wind from the Sea
The white lilies sway,
And the golden bells are shaken of mallos and alfirin
In the green fields of Lebennin,
In the wind from the Sea! TROTK, The Last Debate

[Arothir]

Who am I?

[Drífa]

Are you male?