Who, What, or Where, (In The Name of Arda) Am I?

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you one of the villages of the woodsmen near Eryn Lasgalen in the Anduin valley?

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you one of the villages of the (woods)men near Eryn Lasgalen on the eastside between this forest and the river Celduin? In the north-south direction?

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley
I am not entirely certain what you mean by that description.

[Drífa]

Are you, Aldburg, the dwelling of Éomer in the Folde?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you in the vicinity east of the grand forest? Into Palisor is lots of land to Oricarni.

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley
I am not entirely certain what you mean by that description.
I am not Aldburg
I am in the vicinity east of the grand forest/Mirkwood.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you Celebannon, the trading hub of the Thranduil's people in contact with Dale, Erebor and Esgaroth? It's on the banks of the Taurduin.

[Eamila Bolger]

Are your inhabitants human?

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley
I am not entirely certain what you mean by that description.
I am not Aldburg
I am in the vicinity east of the grand forest/Mirkwood.
I am not Celebannon.
My inhabitants are human.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Are you Dale then on the slopes of Erebor, as this is the only other remaining settlement in the vicinity of Eryn Lasgalen?

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley
I am not entirely certain what you mean by that description.
I am not Aldburg
I am in the vicinity east of the grand forest/Mirkwood.
I am not Celebannon.
My inhabitants are human.
I am not Dale, as there is another inhabited area in the vicinity of Eryn Lasgalen.
I did reread one of the questions and can say that this is an inhabited area between Eryn Lasgalen and the Celduin.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Dorwinion perhaps?

Otherwise there are other unofficial names such as Aur Asgalabar, Uvanwaith and Dor-rhunen. I can't find any other names than Dale, Dorwinion, Esgaroth or Erebor on Tolkien's official maps. The land south and southeast of the Eryn Lasgalen are the thin populated lands of the former Wainriders, and their descendents Aragorn battles with until he defeats them, and bring the land under his jurisdiction.

[Arothir]

I do not exist in the First Age to the best of my knowledge.
I am a place with buildings.
I am not near water.
The buildings were not made by elves.
I am not in a forest.
I am not in Eriador.
I am near Mirkwood.
I am not located near water.
I am not near mountains.
I am still inhabited in the Third Age.
I am not the home of Grimbeorn.
I am not Rhosgobel.
I am not the villages of Woodsmen near Eryn Lashalen in the Anduin Valley
I am not entirely certain what you mean by that description.
I am not Aldburg
I am in the vicinity east of the grand forest/Mirkwood.
I am not Celebannon.
My inhabitants are human.
I am not Dale, as there is another inhabited area in the vicinity of Eryn Lasgalen.
I did reread one of the questions and can say that this is an inhabited area between Eryn Lasgalen and the Celduin.
I am not Dorwinion.

It is worth noting that I am looking for the subregion, where it is noted that a group settled.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Dorwinion is the subregion of Rhûn, also Rómen in Quenya. There is the Eastbight, but I have mentioned that already. I don't believe there is further a known subregion in Dorwinion, it is not named in the article on Tolkien Gateway. If there was it would have been mentioned and there would be reference of it to where it's found in the books.

Somebody else has to try it then. Maybe that person is more succesful?

[Androthelm]

Jumping in very quickly to say that I've spent a bunch of time which I SHOULD have spent studying trying to solve this instead, and I can only think that @Aikári Salmarinian is right and that it is the East Bight? Or the settlements therein? I just want to confirm that that's definitely not the answer before I go absolutely crazy trying to figure this one out, since it didn't make it onto the list of clues.

[Drífa]

Not sure about the subregion, are you Rhovanion?

[Arothir]

The answer is East Bight, my apologies if I missed it earlier.

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Arothir: It's okay, no apologies needed. I was not sure if it was the answer, but thanks. Up for a new round.

Who am I?

[Arothir]

Are you an elf?

[Drífa]

Are you an animal?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).

[Eamila Bolger]

Are you a social being?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.

[Arothir]

Are you one of the Ainur?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.

[Arothir]

Are you human?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.

[Arothir]

Are you in The Lord of the Rings?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.

[Arothir]

Are you in The Hobbit?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.

[Arothir]

Are you in the Silmarillion?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.

[Eamila Bolger]

Have you been in contact with all four hobbits during their journey?

[Arothir]

Are you in The Two Towers?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.

[Arothir]

Are you in The Return of the King?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.
No, I am not in Return of the King.

[Arothir]

Do you appear before the Council of Elrond?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.
No, I am not in Return of the King.
No, I don't appear in Elrond's Council.

[Arothir]

Do you sing any songs?

[Eamila Bolger]

Do you live in a house?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.
No, I am not in Return of the King.
No, I don't appear in Elrond's Council.
Hmm, possible I can sing, but not what you could expect.
Nah, I don't live in an actual house.

[Drífa]

Are you squint-eyed?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.
No, I am not in Return of the King.
No, I don't appear in Elrond's Council.
Hmm, possible I can sing, but not what you could expect.
Nah, I don't live in an actual house.
Nothing known if squint eyed fits me, could be possible.

[Arothir]

Going off of hunch since hobbits, I believe that hobbits are descended from humans, but are you a Hobbit?

[Aikári Salmarinian]

No, I am not an elf.
No, I am not an animal (considered maybe).
I could be a social being, but with a twist.
No, this time I am not one of the Ainur.
No, but I do have human blood in me.
Yes, I am in Lord of the Rings.
No, I am not in the Hobbit.
No, I am not in the Simarillion.
No, I was never in contact with all four hobbits during the journey.
No, I am not in the Two Towers, but I am connected to events happening at that time.
No, I am not in Return of the King.
No, I don't appear in Elrond's Council.
Hmm, possible I can sing, but not what you could expect.
Nah, I don't live in an actual house.
Nothing known if squint eyed fits me, could be possible.
No, I am not even close to Hobbits.

[Arothir]

Do you have a physical form?