Lord of the Rings Fanatics Plaza

Is this character an elf?

Would this entity be able to tell the difference between a cub zirconium necklace and a diamond necklace?

1. No.
2. No.
3. No.
4. I doubt it.

Is this character in The Silmarillion?

Is this person's soul trapped in a necklace?

5. No.
6. No.

Is it Girion, Lord of Dale?

No. (I really enjoy saying 'no' in this game)

Is this person an Elf?

I'll summarise the questions since we have overlap:

Clue: Necklace

1. Does this person look particularly good when wearing a specific necklace? No.
2. Did this person give a necklace to someone as a gift? No.
3. Is this character an elf? No.
4. Would this entity be able to tell the difference between a cub zirconium necklace and a diamond necklace? I doubt it.
5. Is this character in The Silmarillion? No.
6. Is this person's soul trapped in a necklace? No. (who would this be? I can't think of any)

It is not Girion, lord of Dale.

Hur derp, I’m good at paying attention. Let me re ask as:
Does this person use a necklace to perform some sort of task?

Is this person mentioned in The Hobbit?

7. Does this person use a necklace to perform some sort of task? No.
8. Is this person mentioned in The Hobbit? No.

Is the clue referring to a person who wore a physical necklace?

9. Is the clue referring to a person who wore a physical necklace? No.

Is the necklace metaphorical?

10. No.

Did this character make a necklace?

Are they human?

11. No.
12. No.

Is it a creature?

13. Yes.

Can this creature fly?

14. That seems to be unknown. At least, I could not find any primary text evidence for one or the other.

Is it Scatha?

"Thus Fram won great wealth, but was at feud with the dwarves, who claimed the hoard of Scatha. Fram would not yield them a penny, and sent to them instead the teeth of Scatha made into a necklace... Appendix A: The House of Eorl

Is it Scatha the Long-Worm!?

OMG Boromir!!

@Boromir88 got it!

I hope you all enjoyed the nice, big plate of red herring, served by Chef Aduchil.

Another simul with a member of Mordor! Gotta be quicker than that @Winddancer :geek:

New clue: Burned

You are on the list, Boromir. On the list..

Is it in reference to a human?

1. No it does not refer to a human.

Is the character in question mentioned in The Silmarillion?

Is burned a reference to being ill-treated?

Ahh poor Windy. You'll get your win someday.

Is the character in question a protagonist of Lord of the Rings?

Is the character in question a dwarf?

Are they immortal?

Is the character a person who over cooks their food, i.e. breaths fire on it too much?

Are they a servant of Sauron?

2. No, this character is not mentioned in The Silmarillion.
3. No, burned does not refer to this character being ill-treated
4. No, this character is not a protagonist in Lord of the Rings
5. No, this character is not a dwarf.
6. No, this character is not immortal
7. No this character does not breathe fire.
8. No this character is not a servant of Sauron.

You're right @Aduchil , it is fun saying no in this game.

Is this character a hobbit?

9. No this character is not a hobbit.

Did this character burn something?

10. This character did not intend to burn something....but indirectly might have caused the burning to spread.

Is this the chief wolf in The Hobbit, the one that Gandalf hit in the nose with a burning pinecone?

Is this character in the Hobbit?

Is this character involved with the burning of Laketown?

@Almarëa Mordollwen , you got it.

Is this person known for unlocking something, perhaps a door?

1. No

Are they good at riddles?