Who Am I? (A Middle-earth Game)

[Elvheimdros]

New page!

1. No, the clue does not refer to the character's sadness or depression.
2. Yes, this entity would be vulnerable to death by Killer Bunny unless it ran away.
3. No, this person is not associated with the sky.
4. No, this person could not be honestly said to be a wizard.
5. No, this person does not appear in the Silmarillion.
6. No, although it is of course possible, this person is not said to have any blue clothing.
7. No, this individual is not said to wear a blue cloak.
8. No, this is not a dwarf.
9. Yes, this character was alive during Bilbo's life.

10. Yes, this character is human.
11. No, this character never met Bilbo.
12. Yes, this person has definitely killed other beings, and probably gotten literal blood on their hands; but was not accused of murder.
13. No, this person is not primarily associated with water, but could be considered associated by heritage or role.
14. No, it is highly unlikely this person would have a sad song of any genre written about them, and the person's eyes are not blue.
15. No, this person is not known to carry a blade that glows, blue or otherwise.

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

16. Did this character meet any members of the Fellowship at some point?

[Aerlinn]

Does blue refer to this character's heraldry, banner or coat of arms?

[Elvheimdros]

16. Yes, this character met multiple members of the fellowship of the Ring.
17. Yes, blue is a reference to this character's heraldic symbols.

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

Would this character happen to be Faramir?

[Aerlinn]

Is it Imrahil?

[Elvheimdros]

It is not Faramir, but it is Prince Imrahil, whose blue banner is noted in "The Siege of Gondor" at the sortie. Well done @Aerlinn: you're up next.

[Aerlinn]

Tra-la-la-lally! Thanks @Elvheimdros!

Clue: last

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

1. Does "last" refer to the last of this person's bloodline?

[KingODuckingham]

Is this character a protagonist of any major Tolkien storyline?

[Lail]

Does last refer to them arriving at an event last?

[Aerlinn]

1. No, last does not refer to this character's bloodline.
2. No, I would not consider them to be the protagonist of a major Tolkien storyline.
3. No, it does not refer to them arriving last at an event.

[Almarëa Mordollwen]

Was this character alive during the Third Age?

[The Good Hunter]

Does this person feature in the Silmarillion?

[Lail]

Are they in the Hobbit?

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

7. Were they involved in the Last Alliance of Elves and Men?

[Aerlinn]

4. Yes, this character was presumably alive in the Third Age.
5. Yes, this character is in the Silmarillion.
6. No, this character is not in the Hobbit.
7. No, they were not involved the Last Alliance.

[Almarëa Mordollwen]

Would this character be considered one of the Ainur?

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

9. If this character is present in The Silmarillion, and presumably alive in the Third Age, would that make them an Elf?

[Lail]

(If an elf) are they of the Teleri?

[Aerlinn]

8. No, not one of the Ainur.
9. Yes, that would make them an elf.
10. ...............erm....ish?

[The Good Hunter]

Is this person a king?

[Boromir88]

If this character came across the Ring on the side of the road would they suggest throwing it in the sea?

[Lail]

10. fair enough, I expected that might be one of those types of questions.

Did they ever live in Doriath?

[Aerlinn]

11. No, not a king.
12. It seems plausible that they might make such a suggestion?
13. No, they never lived in Doriath.

[Lail]

Is this person a female elf?

[Aerlinn]

14. No, not a female elf.

[Lúthien Tinúviel]

15. was this character involved in the Kinslaying of Alqualonde?

[Boromir88]

Is it Cirdan? Along with Celeborn, he took the last ship from the Grey Havens to leave Middle-earth.

[Aerlinn]

15. I can't say for sure, but I would guess no, not directly involved in the Kinslaying of Alqualonde.

No, not Cirdan.

[Boromir88]

Was this character one of the leaders of the Elves that migrated westward from Cuivienen?

[The Good Hunter]

Does this person have the same name as the last Ruling Steward of Gondor?

[Aerlinn]

16. No, this character did not lead any elves from Cuivienen.
17. No, this character does not share a name with the last Ruling Steward of Gondor.

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this person not in the undying lands at any point in the third age?

[Boromir88]

Well, my last best guess is going to be Maglor? Perhaps the only surviving son of Feanor and Nerdanel. And I mean he did throw a silmaril into the sea, so plausible would suggest the same if he came across the Ring. :idea:

[Aerlinn]

18. No, they are presumably in the Undying Lands for the entirety of the Third Age. (Anything about this character's final fate is unconfirmed in the Silmarillion itself.)

Not Maglor, but your first guess was closer @Boromir88. :smiley8:

[Rivvy Elf]

Is it Nerdanel?

[Androthelm]

Is it Gil-galad, last King of the Noldor in Middle-Earth?

[Aerlinn]

It is not Nerdanel or Gil-galad. Cirdan is still, by quite a bit, the closest guess.

[Balfur]

Did this person return to Middle Earth from the Undying Lands at any point in time?

[Boromir88]

Hmm... @Aerlinn did this person ever meet Cirdan in the First Age?

[Aerlinn]

Aaaaaah, I just found a UT quote that threw me for a bit of a loop. But in the end, I think the only answer it alters is...

15. No, he was definitely NOT involved in the Kinslaying at Alqualonde. And so...

19. No, he did not return to Middle Earth from the Undying Lands.
20. Yes, I think it can be definitely inferred that they met at least once.

[Boromir88]

Ok, so Teleri...ish and did not partake in the kinslaying of Alqualonde. So, maybe one of the children of Finarfin and Earwen. Is it Finrod? I believe he was re-incarnated so he could return and be forever with Amarie. :D

[Almarëa Mordollwen]

Did this person live in Nargothrond at any point?

[Rivvy Elf]

Is this person found in any of the family trees in the silmarillion?

[Aerlinn]

21. No, they did not live in Nargothrond.
22. No, I do not see them in any of the family trees in the Silmarillion.

Which, alas, means that it is not Finrod.

[Elvheimdros]

Was this elf still in Middle Earth when the Noldor returned?

[Balfur]

Is it maybe Voronwë, who was the last of the seven to be send by Círdan into the west and ended up guiding Tuor to Gondolin? It is said that his mother was kin of Círdan, which would make him Teleri-ish (because Sindar/Falathrim).

[Aerlinn]

23. This elf was not still in Middle Earth when the Noldor returned because...

...ding ding! @Balfur has it with Voronwë! I was a bit worried I had messed up the Teleri question so it was a relief to look up the family/elven clan trees. And I didn't realize that he had been born in Nevrast until last night!

[Balfur]

I really shouldn't have stayed up that late yesternight trying to figure it out, but I am glad I did! Especially since I wouldn't have been able to sleep anyway.

My turn, right? Clue: Gold